I found it useful!! I'm using a set of mini mascara. I have repeatedly using this item for long time in my twenties, until I started to concern about fallen fibers looking dirty. I purchased it again for the first time in 6-7 years, it had been reformulated, and I was feeling a bit nostalgic about it. The lengthening effect has a natural look. The previous mascara created bold and long lashes as layering, but it easily formed clumps. I hated the mascara weight forcing lashes downward and making the upper and lower lashes stick together, but this version of mascara keeps upward lashes even when it is layered. The shown color is jet-black, but it seems just a natural black for me. It has a glossy shine, too. There's no longer fibers coming off, which is what I'm most concerned about. This mascara comes off with warm water too, but I'm using eye makeup remover. I feel like it's not as hard on my lashes, since it comes off really cleanly. I use the mini mascara for lower eyelashes, roots, and lashes at the outer corner of the eyes where it's hard to apply.
New formula. 2 shades. From the time of application up until removal, this mascara provides gentle, double eyelash care. With an increased amount of moisturizing cosmetic ingredients, it coats each eyelash with a film that closes off the cuticles of damaged lashes, preventing moisture evaporation. The film solution does not bunch up or clump, producing glossy, beautiful, long eyelashes. It repels sebum, sweat, tears, keeping your eyes beautiful throughout the day. It easily comes off with warm water without causing any burden on the eyes.